MedChunk
Medically reviewed

Why Anal Fissures Recur: Reasons and What Helps

Learn why anal fissures keep coming back, how constipation and muscle spasms affect healing, and which treatments and daily habits may prevent recurrence.

By Caleb Bennett Reviewed by Dr. Irene Medical review dateNov 19, 2026 11 min read

Anal fissures often come back because hard stools, repeated straining, or tight anal muscles can reopen a tear, even after it has healed. A fissure is a small cut in the lining of the anus, where stool leaves the body. Keeping stools soft, improving bowel habits, and treating ongoing muscle tightness can help reduce the chance of another fissure.

Why does an anal fissure keep coming back?

The tissue around the anus stretches whenever stool passes through it. After a fissure heals, another difficult bowel movement or injury can cause the area to tear again. Some people also have ongoing problems that make healing difficult, such as constipation, frequent diarrhea, or tight anal muscles.

According to the American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons, a completely healed fissure can recur following a hard bowel movement or other injury. Continued hard or loose stools, scar tissue, and anal muscle spasms can also interfere with healing.

1. Constipation and hard stools

Constipation is one of the most common reasons fissures develop or return. Large, dry stools stretch the anal opening and can damage its delicate lining. Straining adds pressure to the same area.

Someone may feel better for several weeks after a fissure heals, only to experience pain again following a particularly hard bowel movement. This is why preventing constipation remains important even after symptoms disappear.

2. Tight anal muscles and repeated spasms

The anus contains ring-shaped muscles called sphincters. These muscles help control bowel movements. In some people, the internal sphincter becomes unusually tight.

When a fissure causes pain, the muscle may tighten further. This creates a cycle:

  • A tear causes pain during a bowel movement.
  • The anal muscle tightens or goes into spasm.
  • Muscle tension reduces blood flow to the injured tissue.
  • Reduced blood flow makes healing more difficult.
  • Further bowel movements irritate the area and prolong the cycle.

Cleveland Clinic explains that ongoing muscle tension and reduced blood flow can keep a chronic fissure from healing properly. Treatments that relax the anal sphincter may help interrupt this cycle.

3. Frequent diarrhea or loose stools

Hard stools are not the only cause. Frequent loose bowel movements can also irritate and injure the anal lining. Someone with repeated diarrhea may continue experiencing fissure symptoms even without constipation.

Preventing recurrence therefore means addressing the underlying bowel problem rather than simply increasing fiber without considering the stool pattern.

4. A fissure that has not completely healed

Less pain does not always mean the tear has fully healed. Symptoms may improve before the tissue has recovered completely. If irritating bowel movements continue, the healing process may be interrupted.

A long-lasting fissure is called a chronic anal fissure. Chronic fissures can develop deeper tears, scar tissue, or small skin tags near the anal opening. These changes may make the condition harder to treat than a recent fissure.

5. An underlying medical condition

Sometimes repeated fissures are associated with a medical condition that needs separate attention. Possible contributing problems include inflammatory bowel disease, particularly Crohn's disease, and certain anal infections.

These causes are less common than ordinary bowel-related injury. However, fissures that repeatedly return, fail to heal, or occur in unusual locations deserve professional assessment.

Can a fissure reopen after it has healed?

Yes. A healed fissure does not necessarily provide permanent protection against another tear. Passing a hard stool, straining, or experiencing another injury can cause a new episode.

It is useful to distinguish between two situations:

  • Recurrence: A fissure heals and later develops again.
  • Persistent or chronic fissure: The original tear does not heal completely and continues causing symptoms.

These situations may feel similar, but they can influence treatment decisions. A healthcare professional can assess the history, examine the area, and determine whether further treatment or investigation is appropriate.

What helps prevent anal fissures from returning?

Long-term prevention focuses on passing soft, formed stools without excessive straining and reducing repeated injury to the anal lining.

Keep stools soft with fiber and fluids

Fiber helps support regular bowel movements and can make stools easier to pass. Useful dietary sources include vegetables, fruits, whole grains, and legumes.

Mayo Clinic recommends approximately 25 to 35 grams of fiber daily to help keep stools soft and support fissure healing. Fiber intake should be increased gradually because a sudden increase may cause gas or bloating. Drinking adequate fluids also helps prevent constipation.

Some people benefit from fiber supplements or stool-softening medicines. The appropriate choice depends on bowel habits, other medical conditions, and any medicines already being taken.

Avoid straining and delaying bowel movements

Straining increases pressure around the anus and may reopen healing tissue. Ignoring the urge to pass stool can also make constipation more difficult to manage.

Helpful habits include responding to the natural urge to have a bowel movement, avoiding forceful pushing, and not remaining on the toilet unnecessarily when stool is difficult to pass.

Use warm sitz baths for discomfort

A sitz bath means sitting in shallow, comfortably warm water. Soaking for around 10 to 20 minutes, especially after a bowel movement, can soothe discomfort and help relax the anal muscles.

Warm baths may support healing, but they do not replace treatment for persistent constipation, diarrhea, or chronic muscle spasms.

Address ongoing diarrhea

When frequent loose stools contribute to repeated irritation, the underlying cause may need assessment and treatment. The goal is to achieve comfortable, formed bowel movements rather than simply making stools as soft as possible.

What treatments help when an anal fissure keeps recurring?

If diet changes and improved bowel habits are not enough, medical treatment may help the fissure heal more effectively. The choice depends on whether the fissure is recent or chronic, the degree of muscle tightness, previous treatments, and the person's medical history.

Prescription creams that relax the anal muscle

Clinicians may prescribe topical medicines such as nitroglycerin, diltiazem, or nifedipine. These medicines help relax the internal anal sphincter, which may improve blood flow and allow the tear to heal.

Nitroglycerin can cause headaches and sometimes lower blood pressure. Diltiazem and nifedipine may be alternatives for some patients. These treatments should be used under medical guidance, following the prescribed course.

Botulinum toxin injections

For a persistent fissure, a clinician may consider a botulinum toxin injection into the anal sphincter. The injection temporarily relaxes the muscle and may allow the injured tissue to heal.

The treatment does not guarantee that a fissure will never return. Further treatment may be needed if healing is incomplete or symptoms recur.

Surgery for difficult or repeatedly recurring fissures

When other treatments fail, a colorectal surgeon may discuss lateral internal sphincterotomy. This procedure involves dividing a small portion of the internal anal sphincter to reduce excessive tension.

Surgery is effective for many chronic fissures, but it has risks, including possible difficulty controlling gas or stool. A surgeon considers these risks carefully, especially in people with existing bowel-control problems or previous sphincter injury.

Not everyone with a recurring fissure needs surgery. The NHS explains that medicines and other treatments are usually considered first, while procedures may be recommended when fissures keep returning or do not respond to treatment.

How long does a recurring anal fissure take to heal?

Many recent anal fissures heal within a few weeks with appropriate care. Chronic fissures can take longer and may require prescription treatment or a procedure.

Repeated symptoms over several weeks can suggest that healing is incomplete or that the area is being injured again. The timing alone does not establish the cause.

Continuing healthy bowel habits after pain and bleeding improve is important. Stopping preventive measures as soon as discomfort disappears may leave the same triggers in place.

When should you see a doctor for recurring fissures?

Repeated anal pain or bleeding should be assessed rather than automatically attributed to an old fissure. Hemorrhoids and other anorectal conditions can cause overlapping symptoms.

According to Mayo Clinic, symptoms associated with anal fissures can include pain during bowel movements, pain lasting afterward, and bright red blood on stool or toilet paper. These symptoms are not unique to fissures, so professional evaluation is appropriate.

Arrange medical assessment when:

  • Pain or bleeding repeatedly returns after periods of improvement.
  • Symptoms worsen or fail to improve after about a week of self-care.
  • A previously treated fissure does not heal as expected.
  • Frequent diarrhea, ongoing constipation, or changes in bowel habits accompany the symptoms.
  • Pain significantly interferes with bowel movements or daily activities.

Seek urgent medical attention for heavy or ongoing rectal bleeding, fainting, or severe pain accompanied by fever or significant swelling.

A clinician may review bowel habits, past treatments, and medical history, then gently examine the anal area. Additional tests are sometimes needed when symptoms are unusual or another condition is suspected.

Can recurring anal fissures be prevented permanently?

There is no guaranteed way to prevent every future fissure. However, consistent bowel care and appropriate treatment can substantially reduce the factors that contribute to recurrence.

The most useful long-term approach is to keep stools soft and formed, avoid straining, manage persistent bowel problems, and seek treatment for fissures that do not heal normally.

For people whose fissures repeatedly return despite these measures, addressing anal muscle tension or an underlying medical condition may be more important than continuing home remedies alone.

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about recurring anal fissures, healing, and prevention.

Why does my anal fissure return even when I am not constipated?

Constipation is not the only possible trigger. Frequent loose stools, persistent anal muscle spasms, or incomplete healing can contribute to repeated problems. A healthcare professional can assess whether another condition may be involved.

Can an anal fissure come back in the same place?

Yes. A previously healed area can develop another tear following a hard bowel movement or other injury. If pain repeatedly occurs in the same location, an examination can help distinguish a new tear from a chronic fissure that has not fully healed.

Does a recurring anal fissure always require surgery?

No. Many fissures respond to improved bowel habits, fiber, stool-softening treatments, or prescription creams. Surgery may be considered when a chronic fissure continues despite appropriate treatment or repeatedly returns.

Should I continue eating fiber after my anal fissure heals?

Yes. Maintaining adequate fiber intake can help keep stools soft and lower the likelihood of hard bowel movements that might cause another tear. A balanced diet and adequate fluids remain important after symptoms resolve.

Can an anal fissure return after surgery?

Recurrence after lateral internal sphincterotomy is possible, although it is uncommon when the procedure is successful. Continuing good bowel habits remains helpful. New or persistent pain and bleeding after surgery should be discussed with the treating surgeon.

Citations

  1. American Society of Colon and Rectal Surgeons — Anal Fissure
  2. Cleveland Clinic — Anal Fissures
  3. Mayo Clinic — Anal Fissure: Diagnosis and Treatment
  4. NHS — Anal Fissure
  5. Mayo Clinic — Anal Fissure: Symptoms and Causes
Share this article